To keep mascara from smudging under your eyes, the key is using the right formula and prepping your skin properly. If your lower lash line always ends up with dark smears by noon, you’re not alone and it’s fixable.
This page contains affiliate links. See our disclosure for details.
Smudging happens for a few reasons: excess oil around the eyes, overly moist concealers, or mascaras that don’t set well. Even blinking and natural eye shape can play a role. The trick isn’t just choosing a “waterproof” label — it’s about the full routine working together.
A brief overview
What Causes Mascara to Smudge?
The skin under the eyes is thin and often more hydrated due to eye creams or rich concealers. When mascara rubs off onto this area, it’s usually because:
The formula stays too “wet” too long
Lashes touch the under-eye area often
Oils or creams break down the product
Even your mascara wand shape can matter — bulky brushes can apply too much product.
Tips That Actually Work
Use a tubing mascara – These formulas wrap lashes in a film that resists smudging but washes off with warm water.
Set your under-eye concealer with powder – A light dusting helps prevent oils from mixing with mascara.
Skip heavy eye cream during the day – Save richer formulas for night to keep the area matte.
Apply less on lower lashes – Or skip them entirely if you’re prone to smudging.
A mascara routine that stays put can be the difference between “fresh” and “worn out” especially when combined with other smudge-resistant finds from our curated self-care essentials.
See what else you can master with these beauty tips:
- Top Mascaras for Long Lifted Lashes
- Top Eyeliners That Stay Put All Day
- Top Makeup Removers for Sensitive Skin
- Best Concealers for Dark Circles
Discover more style insights in our full Fashion Answers collection
